The saying goes that you can tell quite a bit about a person from the section of the daily newspaper they turn to first. People usually expect me to turn to the sports page first, but actually, I’m a Comics Page man. It was the first section of the newspaper that I learned to read, and it is still my first stop. The latest bad news from around the world can wait until I’ve gotten my Snoopy on.
As such, here are one man’s opinions about some notable comic strips, past and present:
Time to move on - Comic strips that were great to lift off the page with Play-Doh when I was 10 years old, but that don’t make me laugh any more:
Garfield
Family Circus (I grew up calling it “Family Circle”)
Marmaduke
A comic that probably should be on the above list, but I can’t bring myself to put it there:
Peanuts
Political cartoons worth reading:
Doonesbury (Garry Trudeau sprinted over the line between social commentator and blatant political advocate long ago, but his wit and talent still shine through)
Political comics that go to bed at night dreaming that one day, they too could be Doonesbury:
Non Sequitur (I have stopped even reading this one)
Boondocks (This one is funny when the grandfather is yelling at the boys)
Mallard Fillmore (Never even a little funny)
A comic strip so incredibly hip that I don’t understand it, so I’ve stopped reading it:
Zippy the Pinhead (Ok, so there are some big landmarks that talk to people and….never mind)
Strips that are hidden in your daily paper (please, let’s move the comics back to the Comics page):
Dilbert (in the Business section)
Doonesbury (in the Opinion section)
Tank McNamara (in the Sports section…even on Sundays)
Comics that I actually look forward to reading when I open the paper nowadays:
Zits
Arlo and Janis
Foxtrot
Get Fuzzy (no matter what Bob Lobel thinks)
Mother Goose and Grimm (my wife’s favorite)
A comic that is cool until your friends see you reading it:
Rose is Rose
Comics where the characters age and before long you care about them more than you’d like to admit:
Gasoline Alley
For Better or For Worse
Comics I’ve never read, but that older people still seem to remember fondly:
Lil’ Abner (Who hasn’t heard of Dogpatch?)
Pogo (“We have met the enemy and he is us”)
Serials that I have never cared about in the least:
Brenda Starr
Mark Trail
Gil Thorpe
Occasionally good, but incredibly overrated:
Cathy
Dilbert
You’ll be missed (Ok, not really):
The Big Picture (But, really sorry about your cat and all)
And finally, the Big Three - the three best comic strips of my lifetime:
3. Bloom County: Berkeley Breathed (great name) retired this comic and has since tried to recapture the magic with a couple of strips featuring Opus the Penguin, but they haven’t been close. Give me Mike Binkley and his Anxiety Closet any day.
2. The Far Side: Gary Larson stopped writing this comic, yet continued to sell calendars and books for years afterwards. He was like the Tupac Shakur of the comic strip world; well, except for the gangs, rap music, and violent death.
1. Calvin and Hobbes: Unquestionably the king of all it surveyed until Bill Watterson walked away from it on December 31, 1995. The troublesome tot and his tiger recently made an appearance in a few Sunday newspapers, but it was merely to pump up a soon to be released volume of old strips.
Football fans talk about how Hall of Famers Jim Brown and Barry Sanders walked away from pro football while they were still at their best, thus avoiding the inevitable downward spiral of their careers. Bill Watterson and Gary Larson are the comic strip fan’s equivalent of that story. When they left, it broke their fans’ hearts, but at least they left on top.